Bihar SIR Controversy Reaches Supreme Court: Petitioner Questions ECI's Unanimous Decision Claims

Introduction: Electoral Revision Faces Fresh Legal Questions
India's electoral revision exercise is facing renewed legal scrutiny as questions surrounding the Election Commission's decision-making process continue before the Supreme Court.
The latest development came on November 17, 2026, when a petitioner challenging the functioning of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar questioned whether the Election Commission had produced sufficient original records to establish that important decisions concerning the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) were taken unanimously.
What Happened in the Supreme Court?
According to a LiveLaw report published on November 17, petitioner Rakesh Kumar Singh submitted a rejoinder affidavit disputing the Election Commission's earlier response.
The petitioner argued that the Commission had repeatedly maintained that its decisions relating to SIR were unanimous but had not produced the contemporaneous institutional records needed to establish that position.
The petitioner sought access to documents including:
Agendas and minutes of Commission meetings.
Internal file notings.
Resolutions and circulation sheets.
Electronic approvals.
Relevant institutional communications.
Election Commission's Position
The Election Commission has defended the legality of the SIR exercise in its earlier affidavits.
The poll body maintained that the relevant decisions were taken unanimously and that the revision exercise was legally authorised.
It also disputed allegations concerning changes to Form 6, the statutory application used for voter registration.
Why Is Bihar Important in This Controversy?
Bihar became a major focus of the SIR debate because of the scale of its electoral revision exercise and concerns surrounding voter registration.
The controversy also involves allegations concerning the additional declaration associated with Form 6 and the procedure used to map applicants against earlier electoral rolls.
The Election Commission has maintained that the statutory Form 6 was not amended, although the presentation of the additional declaration was changed to facilitate the mapping process.
Bihar's Electoral Roll Revision Continues
Alongside the legal proceedings, Bihar's electoral administration is continuing its Special Summary Revision for 2027.
According to the draft electoral roll published on November 12, Bihar has approximately 7.55 crore registered electors, around 13 lakh more than the post-SIR figure.
The claims and objections period runs until December 12, 2026, with the final electoral roll scheduled for January 4, 2027.
Conclusion
Bihar's SIR controversy continues to raise important questions about electoral administration, institutional accountability and voter registration.
With fresh arguments presented before the Supreme Court on November 17, the issue remains an important development in India's election politics.









Join the discussion
Comments (0)